Menu
Key Insights:
The ATO is placing greater emphasis on persistent losses and, in particular, whether an activity has genuine prospects of profitability.
Losses alone do not prevent an activity from being a business, with the seven business indicators and existing horse industry rulings continuing to provide the relevant framework.
Horse breeders need to be particularly mindful where ongoing losses are accompanied by non-commercial behaviour, as this combination creates the greatest risk of ATO challenge.
For such a contentious topic, particularly for participants in the thoroughbred industry, the wait for updated ATO guidance on whether an activity is a “business” or a “hobby” has certainly been a long one.
The wait is over with updated guidance now available, albeit in draft form. Last month, the ATO published TR 2026/D2 Income tax: carrying on a business by an individual.
While the horse breeding and racing industries provide a useful context for considering these issues, the draft ruling is not confined to those activities. The same business indicators, including commercial character, profit-making purpose, repetition, organisation and scale are relevant when determining whether other activities are carried on as a business. Nor are these principles limited to individuals. Whilst the draft ruling applies only to individuals, including those in partnership, the principles may also be relevant to activities conducted through companies, trusts and partnerships of entities, although the tax consequences can differ depending on the entity and the particular provisions that apply.
The new draft ruling sets out the indicators the Commissioner considers relevant in determining whether an activity undertaken by an individual is a business, rather than an investment or hobby. The distinction is important because the tax treatment differs. A business may be able to claim tax losses and register for GST, whereas a hobby cannot claim tax losses and generally cannot register for GST. Even where an activity is a business however, the non-commercial loss rules may still prevent a loss from being offset against other income unless the activity satisfies one of the prescribed tests.
The indicators in this draft ruling are consistent with the indicators set out in Taxation Ruling TR 97/11, which set out factors relevant to determining whether a taxpayer carries on a business of primary production for tax purposes. This draft ruling does not replace the more specific advice provided in TR 97/11 and other rulings on this topic and should be read in conjunction with them.
What is significant about the new draft ruling is its explicit focus on persistent losses that cannot be commercially explained. However, persistent losses do not, of themselves, mean that an activity is not a business. The question still requires an overall assessment of the relevant business indicators, rather than applying a fixed threshold based on the amount of the losses or the number of loss-making years.
TR 2026/D2 is best characterised as a consolidation of established business indicators, with a sharper focus of how persistent losses can undermine business status.
Published on 16 October 2026, the draft remains open for consultation until 27 November 2026. Its proposed date of effect would extend to periods before and after publication of the final ruling.
For primary producers, including horse breeders, TR 97/11 remains central. For horse businesses, the industry-specific considerations in TR2008/2, which relates specifically to the horse industry, also remain relevant and are not displaced by the new general framework.
Paragraph 14 identifies seven indicators for an activity to be considered a “business”:
The reduction from TR 97/11’s eight indicators is mainly a change in how the indicators are arranged and explained, rather than a change to the underlying tests. The draft combines businesslike organisation with comparison to the methods of ordinary participants in the relevant industry. Industry comparison has not disappeared.
Whether an activity is a business or hobby is a question of fact, and the ruling makes clear that the indicators must be considered in combination and as a whole.
No indicator is decisive, and their relative importance varies with the circumstances. Accordingly, regular sales, extensive records or substantial expenditure cannot independently establish a business. Equally, small scale does not independently exclude one.
The ruling framework also accommodates changing and unconventional activities. A hobby can become a business when the operator begins conducting it commercially, as examples in the ruling illustrate.
The “content-creator” case study illustrates this transition through monetisation, commercial agreements, investment, advisers and staff, rather than merely the receipt of an initial payment.
Breeders should pay particular attention to what the draft ruling says about losses. In my experience, persistent losses are overwhelmingly the main basis on which the ATO challenges the business status of a horse breeding activity.
Horse breeders can take longer to generate profits because costs are incurred well before horses produce sale income, and developing commercially valuable breeding stock can require several breeding seasons. ATO guidance in TR 2008/2 helps explain why those industry characteristics may mean early losses do not necessarily indicate an uncommercial activity.
Paragraph 30 describes the prospect of profit as “highly significant”, while paragraph 31 warns that where there is little or no real prospect of making a profit, it is unlikely that an activity has a genuine profit-making purpose.
Importantly, however, the ruling does not say that a loss-making activity cannot be a business. Paragraph 32 expressly recognises that an activity may not be expected to make a profit in the short term and may deliberately incur losses while building scale or a customer base.
Even where the objective prospects of profit are poor, business status is not automatically lost. However, the other business indicators will need to be sufficiently strong to outweigh the adverse profitability evidence.
The real concern is where persistent losses are combined with conduct that is objectively inconsistent with a genuine profit-making purpose.
Although the language in the draft ruling is more explicit, the underlying position is substantially unchanged. TR 97/11 already describes profit prospects as “a very important indicator” and recognises that a primary production business may make a small profit or loss in a particular year, including expected short-term losses.
More significantly, paragraph 50 of TR 97/11 already addresses activities that objective evidence suggests may never become profitable:
“Taxpayers need to show that the other indicators of business are present in sufficient strength to outweigh any objective view that the activity may be inherently unprofitable.”
The new draft ruling includes a “consistent loss” case study of which horse breeders should take particular note. It concerns Blaire, who conducts a leather working activity.
Blaire attends markets regularly, develops repeat customers and expects eventually to make a profit. However, her prices remain below full cost and she is unwilling to make the changes necessary to improve profitability because doing so would diminish her enjoyment of the activity.
The ATO concludes that the activity lacks sufficient commercial character and is therefore a “hobby”. Importantly, the problem is not the recurring losses alone. It is the combination of recurring losses, no realistic prospect of profit, recreational motivation and resistance to commercial change. The same reasoning could be applied to a horse breeding or racing activity that is run largely for enjoyment.
The message for horse breeders is clear: persistent losses alone do not mean an activity is not a business. However, the longer losses continue, the more important it becomes to demonstrate that the activity is conducted commercially and has a credible pathway to profitability.
If you would like to discuss the application of this ruling to your business, please contact Paul Carrazzo from our office.